Lobster Roll Restaurant Southampton Menu (Update 2025)
Welcome to Lobster Roll Restaurant Southampton, a gem nestled along Montauk Highway in the heart of Southampton, NY. This casual dining spot celebrates the quintessential coastal culinary experience with its delightful focus on seafood, particularly lobster rolls. With their renowned Cold New England and Warm Connecticut styles, each lobster roll is brimming with fresh, locally sourced lobster that will make your taste buds dance.
The menu also offers a rich array of hearty soups, like the standout Manhattan Seafood Chowder and the beloved Lobster Bisque, both teeming with seafood goodness. Pair your meal with one of their inventive tequila and mezcal cocktails, and you’re set for a memorable dining experience. Whether you're dining in or grabbing a bite to-go, Lobster Roll Restaurant Southampton promises a warm atmosphere and dishes that are sure to leave a lasting impression.
Other Items By The Pound
Coleslaw - 1lb.
Our homemade creamy coleslaw.This item can be Gluten Free!
Lobster Salad - 1lb.
100% pure, cold water lobster meat mixed with our proprietary mayonnaise dressing and celery.This item can be Gluten Free!
Lobster Salad - 1/2 lb.
100% pure, cold water lobster meat mixed with our proprietary mayonnaise dressing and celery.This item can be Gluten Free!
Paul's Famous Seafood Chili - Quart
A spicy blend of shrimp, lobster, scallops, and beans.This item can be Gluten Free!
Lobster Seafood Bisque - Pint
A hearty blend of lobster, shrimp, and scallops with a touch of sherry.Rich and creamy!
Lobster Seafood Bisque - Quart
A hearty blend of lobster, shrimp, and scallops with a touch of sherry.Rich and creamy!
New England Clam Chowder - Pint
Our trademark creamy soup made with lots of clams.
New England Clam Chowder - Quart
Our trademark creamy soup made with lots of clams.
Manhattan Seafood Chowder - Pint
Our own tomato-based soup loaded with clams, shrimp, scallops, and cod.This item can be Gluten Free!
Manhattan Seafood Chowder - Quart
Our own tomato-based soup loaded with clams, shrimp, scallops, and cod.This item can be Gluten Free!
Large, Hot, To-Go Soup
Tequila & Mezcal Cocktails
Tamarind Margarita
Montaukila Blanco, Cointreau, Tamarind Juice, Lime Juice, Agave.
Hot Honey Peach Margarita
Montaukila Anejo, Cointreau, Hot Honey, Peach Juice, Lime Juice, Agave.
Spicy Dragonfruit Margarita
Montaukila Blanco, Cointreau, Muddled Jalapeno, Dragonfruit, Lime Juice, Agave.
Blood Orange Margarita
Blanco tequila, Cointreau, Lime Juice, Blood Orange Juice, Agave
Mezcal Mule
Dos Hombres Mezcal, Lime Juice, Gingerbeer
Spicy Aperol Mezcalita
Montelobos Mezcal, Aperol, Hot Honey, Peach Juice, Lime Juice, Agave
Desert Pear Mezcalita
Montelobos Mezcal, Cointreau, Desert Pear Juice, Lime Juice, Agave
Montaukila Margarita
Montaukila Anejo, Cointreau, Lime Juice, Agave.
Andrea's Guilt-Free Margarita
Blanco Tequila, Cointreau, Lime Juice, Blood Orange Juice.
Pomarita
Montaukila Pomegranate, Cointreau, Lime Juice, Pomegranate Juice, Agave.
Paul's Famous Seafood Chili
A spicy blend of shrimp, lobster, scallops, and beans topped with melted cheddar cheese, sour cream, and scallions. Served with tortilla chips.This item can be Gluten Free!
Louisiana Style Seafood Gumbo
Andouille Sausage, Okra, Cod, Shrimp, & Scallops.Served with rice and two garlic rolls.
Lobster Seafood Bisque - Cup
A hearty blend of lobster, shrimp, and scallops with a touch of sherry.Rich and creamy!
Lobster Seafood Bisque - Crock
A hearty blend of lobster, shrimp, and scallops with a touch of sherry.Rich and creamy!
New England Clam Chowder - Cup
Our trademark creamy soup made with lots of clams.
New England Clam Chowder - Crock
Our trademark creamy soup made with lots of clams.
Manhattan Seafood Chowder - Cup
Our own tomato-based soup loaded with clams, shrimp, scallops, and cod.This item can be Gluten Free!
Manhattan Seafood Chowder - Crock
Our own tomato-based soup loaded with clams, shrimp, scallops, and cod.This item can be Gluten Free!
Soups & Chili
Appetizers
Clams on the Half Shell - 1/2 Dozen
Half dozen, fresh, raw, cold-water clams.This item can be Gluten Free!
Plump Mussels
Served in your choice of an herbed garlic butter or Paul's zesty homemade marinara.This item can be Gluten Free!
Fried Calamari
Lightly seasoned and served with Paul's zesty homemade marinara sauce.
Small Seafood Nachos
A small basket of tortilla chips topped with seafood chili, melted cheddar cheese, sour cream, scallions, and pice de gallo.This item can be Gluten Free!
Small Fish-N-Chip (Minus the Fries)
A small basket of Atlantic cold-water cod dipped in a light batter and fried to crunchy perfection!Served with tartar sauce.Appetizer served without the fries.To be Gluten Free this item would be broiled, not fried.
Small Clam Strips
A small basket of crispy, tender, deep-sea clam strips fried to crunchy perfection.Served with tartar sauce.
Small Popcorn Shrimp
A small basket of crispy popcorn shrimp fried to crunchy perfection!Served with cocktail or tartar sauce.To be Gluten Free this item would be broiled, not fried.
Crab Dip
Served with tortilla chips.
Clams on the Half Shell - Full Dozen
Full dozen, fresh, raw, cold-water clams.This item can be Gluten Free!
Fried Buffalo Calamari
Served with hot sauce and bleu cheese.
Seafood Nachos
A small or large basket of tortilla chips topped with seafood chili, melted cheddar cheese, sour cream, scallions, and pice de gallo.This item can be Gluten Free!
Fish-N-Chip (Minus the Fries)
A large basket of Atlantic cold-water cod dipped in a light batter and fried to crunchy perfection!Served with tartar sauce.Appetizer served without the fries.To be Gluten Free this item would be broiled, not fried.
Fried Clam Strips
A large basket of crispy, tender, deep-sea clam strips fried to crunchy perfection.Served with tartar sauce.
Popcorn Shrimp
A large basket of crispy popcorn shrimp fried to crunchy perfection!Served with cocktail or tartar sauce.To be Gluten Free this item would be broiled, not fried.
Wings
Eight wings tossed in your choice of Hot Sauce, BBQ, or Garlic Parmesan. Served with either Bleu Cheese or Ranch.
Steamed Clams
A dozen steamed clams. Served with drawn butter.This item can be Gluten Free!
Shrimp Cocktail
Six jumbo shrimp served with cocktail sauce.This item can be Gluten Free!
Chicken Tenders
Eight chicken tenders fried crispy and golden. Served with your choice of sauce.Appetizer served without the side.This item can be Gluten Free!
Mozzarella Sticks
Served with Paul's homemade zesty marinara sauce.
Garden Salad
Romaine, Kale, Frisee, Raddichio, Cucumbers, Red Peppers, Shredded Carrots, Purple Cabbage.Served with your choice of dressing.This item can be Gluten Free!
Caesar Salad
Romaine, Croutons, Parmesan Cheese, Caesar Dressing.This item can be Gluten Free!
Salads
Protein Salads
Veggie Burger over Salad
Dr. Praeger's Veggie Burger over your choice of our Garden Salad or Caesar Salad.This item can be Gluten Free!
1 PC Chicken over Salad
Herbed Chicken Cutlet over your choice of our Garden Salad or Caesar Salad.This item can be Gluten Free!
2 PC Chicken over Salad
Two herbed chicken cutlets over your choice of our Garden Salad or Caesar Salad.This item can be Gluten Free!
Crabcakes over Salad
Two of our crab cakes over your choice of our Garden Salad or Caesar Salad.
Salmon over Salad
Salmon prepared with a garlic herb sauce. Served over your choice of our Garden Salad or Caesar Salad.This item can be Gluten Free!
Tuna over Salad
Select loin-cut Tuna steak lightly marinated in garlic and herbs. Served over your choice of our Garden Salad or Caesar Salad.This item can be Gluten Free!
Shrimp over Salad
Wild caught, jumbo shrimp, "Scampi-Style" - broiled to perfection. Served over your choice of our Garden Salad or Caesar Salad.This item can be Gluten Free!
Fish of the Day over Salad
Fish of the Day - Currently Striped Bass.Served over your choice of our Garden Salad or Caesar Salad.This item can be Gluten Free!
Classic Lobster Salad Roll
100% pure, cold water lobster meat mixed with our proprietary mayonnaise dressing and celery.Served cold on a hot, toasted split-top bun with a side of coleslaw.
Classic Lobster Salad Roll "Special"
100% pure, cold water lobster meat mixed with our proprietary mayonnaise dressing and celery.Served cold on a hot, toasted split-top bun. Comes with coleslaw and your choice of either french fries or sweet fries.
Hot Lobster Roll
Hot, tasty chunks of claw and knuckle meat served in drawn butter with a toastedsplit-top bun on the side. Comes with a side of coleslaw.
Hot Lobster Roll "Special"
Hot, tasty chunks of claw and knuckle meat served in drawn butter with a toastedsplit-top bun on the side. Comes with a side of coleslaw and your choice of french fries or sweet fries.
Classic Lobster Salad Sliders
Our classic lobster salad on two toasted slider buns. Comes with a side of coleslaw.
Soup 'N' Sliders
The Best of Both Worlds! Our classic lobster salad sliders served with a cup of either our homemade Manhattan Seafood or New England Clam Chowder. Lobster Bisque (Extra $1.00)This item can be Gluten Free!(Gluten Free soup option would be Manhattan Seafood Chowder.)
Lobster Rolls
Lobster Bowls
Lobster Salad Bowl
100% pure, cold water lobster meat mixed with our proprietary mayonnaise dressing and celery.Served cold on a garden salad with coleslaw and your choice of dressing.
Hot Lobster Bowl
Hot, tasty chunks of claw and knuckle meat served on a garden salad. Served with a side of coleslaw and your choice of dressing.
Lobster Seafood Mac 'N' Cheese
Fontina Cheese Sauce with Lobster, Scallops & Shrimp. Served with either a side salad and your choice of dressing or broccoli.
Lobster Grilled Cheese
Hot, tasty chunks of claw and knuckle meat served on a grilled cheese. Comes with a side of coleslaw.
Special Items
Tacos
Fish Tacos
Seasoned North Atlantic Cod fried to perfection. (Broiled for gluten free)Two tacos topped with homemade pico de gallo, cabbage slaw, roasted corn, and chipotle mayonnaise. Served on soft flour tortillas (corn tortillas for gluten free) and a side of coleslaw.
Shrimp Tacos
Seasoned Popcorn Shrimp fried to perfection. (Broiled for gluten free)Two tacos topped with homemade pico de gallo, cabbage slaw, roasted corn, and chipotle mayonnaise. Served on soft flour tortillas (corn tortillas for gluten free) and a side of coleslaw.
Lobster Tacos
Hot, tasty chunks of claw and knuckle meat.Two tacos topped with homemade pico de gallo, cabbage slaw, roasted corn, and chipotle mayonnaise. Served on soft flour tortillas (corn tortillas for gluten free) and a side of coleslaw.
8oz. Char-Broiled Black Angus Brisket Beef Burger
8oz. Black Angus beef burger. Comes with coleslaw and your choice of a side.This item can be Gluten Free!
Char-Broiled Chicken Breast Pub
Herbed chicken cutlet served with honey mustard, coleslaw, and your choice of a side.This item can be Gluten Free!
Golden Grilled Cheese
The old "standby" - grilled golden brown. Served with coleslaw and your choice of a side.This item can be Gluten Free!
All - Beef Hot Dog
Grilled classic on a buttery toasted roll. Served with coleslaw and your choice of a side.This item can be Gluten Free!
Grandma's Old Fashioned Grilled Crabcake
Blue claw crabcake served with remoulade, coleslaw, and your choice of a side.
Fried Flounder Filet Pub
Breaded and deep fried, served with tartar sauce, coleslaw, and your choice of a side.
Broiled Flounder Filet Pub
Fresh, boneless filet broiled in butter. Served with coleslaw and your choice of a side.This item can be Gluten Free!
Char-Broiled Tuna Steak Pub
Fresh tuna loin steak served with remoulade sauce, coleslaw, and your choice of a side.This item can be Gluten Free!
6oz. Char-Broiled Black Angus Brisket Beef Burger
6oz. Black Angus beef burger. Comes with coleslaw and your choice of a side.This item can be Gluten Free!
Chicken BLT
Grilled or Fried chicken cutlet served on your choice of bread. Comes with coleslaw and your choice of a side.To be Gluten Free choose Grilled, not Fried.
Dr. Praeger's Grilled Veggie Burger Pub
A healthful blend of select veggies, delicately seasoned, and served with honey mustard. Comes with coleslaw and your choice of a side.This item can be Gluten Free!
Pub Sandwiches
Fried Entree Items
Chicken Tenders 'N' Chips
Chicken tenders fried crispy and golden. Served with your choice of sauce.Comes with coleslaw and your choice of a side.This item can be Gluten Free!
First Mate's Fried Combination
Breaded Shrimp, Clam Strips, and Flounder. Comes with coleslaw and your choice of a side.Served with tartar and cocktail sauce.
Fried Filet of Flounder
Lightly breaded, fresh boneless filet. Served with tartar sauce, coleslaw, and your choice of a side.
Golden Fried Shrimp
Jumbo Shrimp, lightly breaded and fried golden brown.Comes with coleslaw and your choice of a side.
Chicken Cutlet Platter
Pure white meat chicken filet brushed with a garlic herb sauce. Served with coleslaw and your choice of a side.This item can be Gluten Free!
Broiled Seafood Combination
Jumbo Shrimp, Scallops, and Flounder. Served with scampi butter, coleslaw, and your choice of a side.This item can be Gluten Free!
Broiled Filet of Flounder
Fresh, boneless filet broiled in butter. Served with coleslaw and your choice of a side.This item can be Gluten Free!
Scampi - Style Shrimp
Jumbo shrimp "Scampi-Style" - broiled to perfection. Served with coleslaw and your choice of a side.This item can be Gluten Free!
Salmon Filet
Prepared with a garlic herb sauce. Served with coleslaw and your choice of a side.This item can be Gluten Free!
Tuna Steak
Select loin-cut steak lightly marinated in garlic and herbs. Served with coleslaw and your choice of a side.This item can be Gluten Free!
Fish of the Day
Currently Striped Bass. Served with coleslaw and your choice of a side.This item can be Gluten Free!
Broiled & Char-Broiled Entree Items
Classic Entrees & Lobsters
Fish 'N' Chips
A large basket of Atlantic cold-water cod dipped in a light batter and fried to crunchy perfection. Malt vinegar completes the dish!Served with tartar sauce.To be Gluten Free this item would be broiled, not fried.
Grandma's Crabcakes
Grilled, premium blue claw crabmeat, bread crumbs, spices, and herbs. Served with remoulade sauce, coleslaw, and your choice of a side.
Baked Stuffed Flounder
A house favorite! Crabmeat stuffing with mild melted cheese. Finished with scampi butter. Comes with coleslaw and your choice of a side.
Baked Stuffed Shrimp
Our homemade crabmeat stuffing atop jumbo shrimp, baked to perfection. Comes with coleslaw and your choice of a side.
Steamed Whole Lobster
1 1/2 lb. Lobster.The tomalley and roe are removed from the lobster unless otherwise requested.This item can be Gluten Free!
Soft Shell Crab Basket
Two fried, panko-crusted soft shell crabs served with coleslaw and your choice of a side.
Stuffed Twin Lobster Tails
Two lobster tails with crabmeat stuffing served with coleslaw and your choice of a side.
Specials
Sides
French Fries
This item can be Gluten Free!
Sweet Fries
This item can be Gluten Free!
Roasted New Potatoes
This item can be Gluten Free!
Corn
This item can be Gluten Free!
Broccoli
This item can be Gluten Free!
Coleslaw
This item can be Gluten Free!
Small French Fry
This item can be Gluten Free!
Vanilla Cupcake
Vanilla cupcake topped with homemade vanilla buttercream frosting.
Chocolate Cupcake
Devil's food chocolate cupcake topped with homemade chocolate ganache frosting.
White & Black Cupcake
Vanilla cupcake topped with homemade chocolate ganache frosting
Black & White Cupcake
Devil's food chocolate cupcake topped with homemade vanilla buttercream frosting.
Coconut Cream Cupcake
Vanilla cupcake topped with homemade coconut cream frosting.
Oreo Cupcake
Devil's food chocolate cupcake topped with homemade vanilla buttercream frosting and oreo cookies.
GF Chocolate Cupcake with Homemade Vanilla Buttercream
This item is Gluten Free!
GF Chocolate Cupcake with Homemade Chocolate Ganache
This item is Gluten Free!
"LUNCH" Cupcake
Vanilla cupcake topped with homemade vanilla buttercream frosting decorated with gummy sea critters.
Cupcakes
Pies & Specialty Items
Double-Crust Fruit Pie
Different flavors available seasonally! Ask your server for the selection!
Fruit Crisp Ala Mode
Seasonal fruit baked with a buttery crumb topping and served with vanilla ice cream.
Chocolate Obsession Cake
A rich, dense, "chocolatey" cake topped with a velvety, smooth, creamy, chocolate ganache frosting.A must for chocolate lovers! Served warm with whipped cream.
Frozen Key Lime Pie
Creamy, tangy and refreshing filling with a slightly sweet graham cracker crust.
Key Lime Tart
Graham Cracker crust with a Key Lime Filling.